In brief
- SAMHSA's framework begins by finding out what a community needs.
- A coalition can bring together people with different kinds of local knowledge.
- Programs may be intended for a whole setting or for young people in specific circumstances.
- Evaluation looks at what was delivered and what happened.
Start with a local question
Substance use prevention can take place at home, in school, or through a community program. The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) starts its Strategic Prevention Framework with the conditions in a community. Data about what is happening and knowledge of the surrounding circumstances can help a group define the problem it will address. A question about which age group reports a particular pattern is different from a question about what services or activities are already available to that group.
A national trend is useful context for that work. The overview of teen substance use research describes how a national student survey measures what students report over different periods. SAMHSA's framework puts local data to a different use. Its starting point is a community's own needs, and the group keeps using data when it chooses a program and when it looks at progress. For instance, local data might help distinguish a change in how often a substance is used from a change in how young people think about it. Each question calls for a measure that answers it.
From assessment to evaluation
SAMHSA describes assessment as finding the community's needs using local data. This means being specific enough to identify a population or a setting. A report covering a county can give a broad picture, while the resources available to families may vary from one neighborhood to the next. Assessment helps a coalition name the question it has enough information to consider and where it needs a clearer picture.
SAMHSA calls the next part capacity, meaning the resources and readiness a community has to address the need. A coalition may have access to information through one organization and a place to run a program through another. The framework's capacity step also asks how to share knowledge about prevention. That makes the people available to do the work a separate consideration from the size of the problem.
The planning step in SAMHSA's framework considers which approaches have evidence behind them and how they could be carried out for the local need. For a community considering a school program, the setting a program was designed for and the young people it was tested with are relevant to that choice. SAMHSA's implementation step describes delivering the selected practice as intended. What a program is designed to include and what a community has the resources to deliver are distinct pieces of information.
In the evaluation step, SAMHSA looks at both process and outcomes. Process means how a program was carried out. It can include whether the planned activities took place or whether the program reached the group it was meant for. Outcomes are changes the evaluation measures after the program is put in place. Reaching participants is one piece of evidence about delivery. Whether the measure of interest changed is another.
Why SAMHSA describes this as team work
SAMHSA's account of the framework gives community partners a role at every step because they bring different experiences and knowledge. A school team may understand the choices students encounter during the school day, while a family organization may know which kinds of information relatives are seeking. A coalition can use both perspectives when it defines a need or decides whether a proposed program fits local conditions. SAMHSA notes that the people and institutions involved may change as the initiative changes.
The same SAMHSA framework describes the work as a cycle. Communities return to assessment as their needs and resources change, and they may be working on several steps at once. A coalition looking at early participation can be evaluating one part of the work while still building capacity to reach another group. That combination helps explain why the framework has room to revisit a choice after seeing what happens in practice.
What programs are designed to address
The National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) describes research-based programs for families, schools, and communities that address circumstances associated with greater or lower likelihood of drug use. Researchers call these risk and protective factors, as NIDA's addiction overview explains. NIDA lists positive relationships and neighborhood resources as protective factors, and lists availability of drugs at school among the risk factors. These terms help specify what a program is designed to change. They describe influences and circumstances that can vary across people and places.
NIDA reports that studies of research-based programs have found reductions in early use of tobacco, alcohol, and other drugs. The agency uses research-based for programs developed from scientific evidence and tested. A description of the people and settings in that research helps a coalition understand what the study covered when it considers the program for a local need.
NIDA's overview calls a program universal when it addresses factors shared across a setting, such as a school. It calls a program selective when it is designed for a group of young people with circumstances associated with a greater chance of substance use. It calls a program indicated when it is designed for young people who have already started using drugs. The terms describe which young people a program is intended to reach. An approach open to an entire school and one designed for students who have already used a substance may therefore have different activities and measures.
NIDA says prevention programs are designed for different ages and can take place with individuals or groups, including at home or in school. Family activities may have a narrower focus than a community plan. The page on parenting and family support programs describes family education, and the page on conversations about alcohol and drugs describes the aims of SAMHSA's materials for parents and caregivers.